Can Fiction Writers Go Both Ways?
I’ve never encountered a fiction writer I considered excellent at both the novel and short story forms. Peter Taylor’s short stories are excellent, his novels not so much. Anyone who knows me is tired of my effusions about Faulkner’s novels but have you ever heard me rave about any of his short stories?
Here’s another example: I recently checked out Roxana Robinson’s “Asking for Love” from the library by mistake (I rarely read short stories). It was the last thing on my shelf so I plowed into it. The stories are exquisite!
So now I’m reading “This is My Daughter” and it’s drudgery. Is it just me?
